i-base

Activists convince Washington Post that Pfizer lowers prices: global action highlights fairer alternatives – this story has been removed!

Simon Collins, HIV i-Base

IMG_3047

Demonstrators in New York

The dominant market structure where pharmaceutical drug pricing blocks access to otherwise cheap-to-manufacture life-saving medicines from the people who most need them, was highlighted by international activists on Friday.

This was a coordinated action linking community-based organisations from seven countries and directed against several large international pharmaceutical companies including Pfizer, Gilead and Roche.

In New York, the release of a press release on 31 March 2016, linked to a mirror website for the pharmaceutical company Pfizer, was picked up and reported by several leading new outlets including the Washington Post and the managed market journal AJMC.com. [1, 2]

AU-Washington Post coverage

Pfizer news covered by the Washington Post

The Pfizer-like document detailed how, after such profitable years, the company were announcing a new model for pricing that would enable their drugs to be more widely used:

“For many years we have calculated our initial drug prices by linking them to high research and development costs or to their market value. We have also had a policy of increasing prices over what is needed to stay above inflation” said Pfizer CEO Ian C. Read. “Our new analysis reveals that these price increases have made many of our products inaccessible so we are planning to walk prices back toward a more reasonable figure.” Following recommendations found in PhRMA’s “A Sustainable Pricing Plan for the 21st Century” Pfizer will reassess its pricing calculation method. Referring to Pfizer’s recent campaign to raise awareness about the disputed cost of research and development Mr. Read continued “The figure of $2.87 billion quoted by DiMasi et al. in a recent paper was so out of line with our own actual costs that it led us to reconsider our entire pricing process.”

From ACT-UP coverage

Spokesperson from ACT-UP coverage of the demo

Given these views echo those widely held by people who want fairer access to medicine, it is understandable how the story was easily reprinted.

And outside Pfizer offices in New York on 1st April 2016, more than 100 vocal and lively protesters, many of them from ACT-UP, were met by “an official company statement from a Pfizer representative” who announced “a plan to enable global access to life-saving medication by lowering price, called a sutainable pricing structure for the 21st century”.

IMG_3026Following cheers from the crowd, the spokeperson continued: “This plan ties the price of drugs to the real research and development costs, while still guaranteeing a reasonable profit for our investors. Medication will now be priced so that every patient who needs them can get them.” [3, 4]

Although, the original articles were removed within a few hours of being published – and the official spokesperson was an actor – the belief that prices could be lower and companies could still make profits accounts for the original rapid reports. The Washington Post website now has “article removed” messages and the AJMC story remains only as ghost google traces. [5, 6]

AU- story remove

Washington Post removal page

The “fake” press release is actually very convincing in showing alternative pricing policies that would work for people and still provide profits.

April Fools day was an appropriate choice for action against excessive drug pricing and lack of transparency for development costs. Coordinated by activists in seven countries, who realised that this is far from a joke for people who’s lives depend on medicines that are held out of reach.

The action demanded an end to:

Other actions took place in London, Johannesburg, Tokyo, San Francisco, Delhi, New York, Boston, Washington, Paris, Ahmedabad, Rio and Brazilia.

At Gilead's London office

ACT UP at Gilead’s London office

In London, members of ACT-UP UK protested inside offices of Gilead HQ wearing only painted letters on their back to spell out pharma greed. Reported widely, including in the Guardian and thebody.com. [7, 8]

In Johannesburg, members of the Fix the Patent Laws campaign, including Advocates for Breast Cancer, the Cancer Alliance, CANSA, Doctors without Borders, People Living with Cancer, SECTION27, the South African Non-Communicable Diseases Alliance, the Treatment Action Campaign and Wings of Hope picketed outside pharmaceutical company Roche to highlight the excessive price of a life-saving breast cancer medicine. [9]

In Boston, AIDS activists and medical students protested the research from Joseph DiMasi at Tufts University over industry funding disclose relating to DiMasi’s estimates of development costs used by drug companies to justify astronomical prices. [10]

PharmaGreedKills India

Demostrators at Ahmedabad

In India, activists highlighted drug pricing in a country where more than 70% of people live on less than $2 a day and health insurance is inadequate. India contribute roughly 1% of its total gross domestic product to healthcare, which is arguably among the lowest levels of funding in the world. [11]

In Paris and Tokyo, activists protested against Gilead for their pricing of drugs to treat hepatitis C demanding this should be closer to the cost of production. [12, 13]

By coincidence, a genuine press release by GSK, also on 31 March 2016, expaned policies for greater access to medicines drugs in low income settings to include cancer in addition to HIV drugs. [14]

References

  1. Washington Post. Pfizer vows to stop raising the list prices of its drugs
    http://canmua.net/washington/pfizer-vows-to-stop-raising-the-list-prices-of-its-603259.html
  2. Joszt L. Pfizer Will Halt Routine Price Increases and Even Reduce Price on Some Drugs (31 March 2016). AMJC.com. Google web cache.
    http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:HsOFkV2cqYUJ:www.ajmc.com/newsroom/pfizer-will-halt-routine-price-increases-and-even-reduce-price-on-some-drugs+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us
  3. ACT-UP website. ACT UP protests pharma greed at Pfizer. 2 April 2016.
    http://actupny.com/actions
    https://www.youtube.com/embed/uRiBjMUg1sM
    (web video)
  4. PharmaGreedKills website. New York. (2 April 2016).
    http://www.pharmagreedkills.com/#!new-york/dhi43
  5. Washington Post. This story has been removed.
    https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/03/31/pfizer-vows-to-stop-raising-the-list-prices-of-its-drugs
  6. AMJC.com. Pfizer will halt routine price increases and even reduce price on some drugs. 1 April 2016.  Archived in a search for Pfizer.
    http://www.ajmc.com/search?get1=search&keywordTerm=Pfizer
  7. The Guardian. AIDS activists go bare to target austerity. (1 April 2016).
    https://www.theguardian.com/science/political-science/2016/apr/01/aids-activists-go-bare-to-target-austerity
  8. TheBody.com. Chanting ‘pharma greed kills,’ HIV and health justice groups protest across time zones and continents.
    http://www.thebody.com/content/77368/chanting-pharma-greed-kills-hiv-and-health-justice.html
  9. PharmaGreedKills website. Johannesburg.(2 April 2016).
    http://www.pharmagreedkills.com/#!johannesburg/cymx3
  10. PharmaGreedKills website. AIDS activists and medical students stage die-in to call upon Tufts CSDD researcher Joseph DiMasi to disclose funders.(2 April 2016).
    http://www.pharmagreedkills.com/#!boston/n2m9m
  11. PharmaGreedKills website. Ahmedabad (2 April 2016).
    http://www.pharmagreedkills.com/#!ahmedabad/tuklt
  12. PharmaGreedKills website. Paris. (2 April 2016).
    http://www.pharmagreedkills.com/#!paris/rbd5i
  13. PharmaGreedKills website. Tokyo. (2 April 2016).
    http://www.pharmagreedkills.com/#!tokyo/geqbf
  14. GSK. GSK expands graduated approach to patents and intellectual property to widen access to medicines in the world’s poorest countries. (31 March 2016)
    http://www.gsk.com/en-gb/media/press-releases/2016/gsk-expands-graduated-approach-to-patents-and-intellectual-property-to-widen-access-to-medicines-in-the-world-s-poorest-countries